Parent Presses MTSD for Evidence, Clearer Guidelines on Student Screen Use
Nicholas Mistretta
MONTGOMERY, NJ — The ongoing community discussion over student screen time returned to the Montgomery Township Board of Education on Tuesday night, as resident Joanna Malecka challenged the district to provide clearer evidence supporting the use of technology in instruction and renewed calls for more consistent guidelines and parent involvement.
Speaking during public comment at the Board’s Nov. 17 meeting, Malecka followed up on the district’s Nov. 9 Superintendent Series session, “Growing Up Digital: K-4 Technology Usage at MTSD,” where administrators outlined current technology practices in Montgomery’s elementary schools. Malecka, who has repeatedly raised concerns about screen exposure at Board meetings, began by thanking the district for meeting with parents but said one central question remained unanswered. “What scientific evidence are we using to decide that technology provides better learning outcomes than traditional teaching methods?” Malecka asked. She acknowledged that district officials had discussed benefits such as real-time feedback and adaptive learning programs during the Nov. 9 session, but argued that those features should not automatically be treated as evidence of better educational outcomes. “We heard about real-time feedback and adaptive programs, but those are features of technology, not evidence that children actually learn better,” she said.
Malecka Points to Broader Reconsideration of Screen Use
Malecka told the Board that Montgomery should consider what she described as a broader reassessment of technology use taking place in other educational systems. She cited New York City and Los Angeles school systems as examples of districts that have moved toward screen-time limits and pointed to Sweden’s increased emphasis on printed textbooks and handwriting after years of expanding classroom technology. Malecka also referenced Princeton University, saying the university introduced an “analog classroom” pilot this fall encouraging handwritten notes and printed materials, with some professors also returning to handwritten examinations. “Shouldn’t we be paying attention to why these institutions are reconsidering technology?” she asked.
Questions District’s Screen-Time Measurements
Malecka also questioned whether the district’s current screen-time figures capture the full amount of digital exposure students experience during the school day. At the Nov. 9 Superintendent Series meeting, district officials reported that students at Orchard Hill Elementary School spend less than 30 minutes per day on individual devices, while Village Elementary School students spend less than 45 minutes per day. Administrators emphasized at that meeting that individual device use is primarily intended for reinforcement activities and that core instruction remains teacher-led. Malecka said Tuesday that she learned during the session that interactive classroom boards are not included in those individual-device figures. “Shouldn’t we measure total classroom screen exposure?” she asked. She also offered a personal example involving her middle-school-aged child, telling the Board that GoGuardian data showed an average of three hours and six minutes of Chromebook use per day over the previous 30 days, with the reported websites identified as education-related.
Calls for Consistency Across Classrooms
Another concern raised by Malecka centered on teacher discretion. During the Superintendent Series session, administrators repeatedly emphasized purposeful technology use and teacher judgment, including when discussing videos during snack periods, dismissal and other non-instructional portions of the school day. Malecka said she respects teacher autonomy but questioned whether some districtwide standards should nevertheless be established. “Shouldn’t we have consistent guidelines across classrooms?” she asked. Her question reflects one of the issues that has surfaced repeatedly in the local discussion: whether broad district principles are sufficient or whether Montgomery should establish more specific expectations governing when and how digital tools are used with students.
Parent-Teacher Working Group Remains a Concern
Malecka also returned to a proposal that parents have raised for several months — creation of a working group involving parents and educators to examine technology and screen use. “From what I understand from last week’s meeting, this group will not be formed,” Malecka said. Malecka concluded by urging the district not to allow the discussion to fade. “Our children have only one childhood,” she said. “Their brains are developing at an extraordinary pace, forming foundations that will last a lifetime. We cannot give them those years back again.” “Please don’t dismiss parents’ voices in this discussion,” she added. “This is an important conversation and we can’t wait.”
Photo by: Nicholoas Mistretta/headlinenewsmontgomery.com











